Tell us how you used this resourceSuggest a green growth resource

Browse by:

Sector

Country

Region

Theme

Organisation

Type

You are here

Home > Databases > Library > Pipe Dreams: Why Canada's proposed pipelines don't fit in a low carbon world

Pipe Dreams: Why Canada's proposed pipelines don't fit in a low carbon world

July 2020
Source: 
Carbon Tracker Initiative
Pipe_Dreams_CTI

This resource discusses the future of Canada's oil sand pipeline projects. Prospective pipeline projects represent a significant expansion of capacity, with taxpayer support. However, new pipelines are surplus to requirements under Paris Agreement demand levels.

The report reveals:

  • All proposed new pipelines from Western Canada, in particular Keystone XL and Trans Mountain expansion, are surplus to requirements in a Paris-compliant world;
  • Even if discounts for Canadian crude narrow, new oil sands projects remain uneconomic;
  • Investors in oil sands face depressed cash flows in a low carbon world of falling oil demand and weak pricing, but will be forced to produce or pay the price due to inflexible “take-or-pay” transport fees for excess new pipeline capacity;
  • While take-or-pay contracts spread the impacts, pipeline investors still face financial risks as upstream production weakens;
  • The Canadian government’s stakes in Keystone XL and Trans Mountain could well prove to be a drain on the public purse.

Canadian authorities face the challenge of trying to reconcile their natural resources development plans with their positioning on climate. Canada has previously having shown leadership on climate change issues, but its government support for pipelines – which are reliant on the failure of the Paris Agreement – risks damaging its credibility.

 
Read online
Sectors: 
Energy
Themes: 
Trade and Supply Chains, Infrastructure
Key search terms: 
oil sand pipeline, Paris Agreement, oil demand, oil and gas

Related Research

October 2018

Comprehensive Wealth in Canada 2018: Measuring what matters in the long term

International Institute for Sustainable Development (IISD)
The report Comprehensive Wealth in Canada 2018: Measuring what matters in the long term tries to measure the comprehensive wealth in Canada. Comprehensive wealth in this report means the country's produced, natural, human, financial and social capital. The findings of the report suggest that the concerns for Canada's future in terms of comprehensive wealth is well-founded as the analysis demonstrates that the foundation of the GDP growth is fragile.
January 2019

Leveraging Sustainable Finance Leadership in Canada: Opportunities to align financial policies to support clean growth and a sustainable Canadian economy

International Institute for Sustainable Development (IISD)
In advance of Canada’s Expert Panel on Sustainable Finance releasing their recommendations on the best finance and investment structures for climate action, Leveraging Sustainable Finance Leadership in Canada sets out a three-year policy roadmap to funnel private investment into a sustainable Canadian economy.
June 2020

Absolute Impact: Why oil majors' climate ambitions fall short of Paris limits

Carbon Tracker Initiative
This report provides a relative ranking of climate goals for a selection of the largest oil and gas producers (7 majors plus Equinor and Repsol), based on CTI's assessment framework which is described in detail.
September 2019

Breaking the Habit - Why none of the large oil companies are "Paris-aligned", and what they need to do to get there

Carbon Tracker Initiative
The report looks at the alignment of major oil and gas companies to the Paris Agreement. It finds that last year, all of the major oil companies sanctioned projects that fall outside a “well below 2 degrees” budget on cost grounds.